archetech / archon / 30063254119

90%

main: 90%

Pull #767

github

docs: correct overclaims flagged in whole-paper review

Addresses the inline findings that concern claims this PR introduced or
directly contradicts. The structural recommendations (reorganization,
citations, 6.5, 10.1, 13) are deliberately not in this commit — see PR
discussion.

- Abstract: still called the resolution interface conformant while 5.5
  documents two deviations. Same fix-one-instance-miss-its-twin failure
  as the previous round. Now describes the Universal Resolver-style
  interface with a pointer to the deviations. Dropped "unprecedented"
  and narrowed "zero-cost" to no registry transaction fee.

- 9.3 / 12.1 (P1): "selective disclosure through encrypted
  presentations" and "present credentials selectively" described a
  property we do not have. The presentation path encrypts the entire
  signed credential for the verifier — recipient confidentiality, not
  claim-level disclosure. Stated the distinction and pointed at 14.1 as
  unimplemented future work, resolving the contradiction with 14.

- 15 (P1): "privacy-preserving voting" materially overstated.
  computePollResults() builds keyToMember[ballotKey] = memberDID,
  decrypts every ballot, and spoil is vote: 0, so the organizer can link
  choices to voters. Reframed as encrypted ballot collection with
  organizer-visible ballots.

- 15 (P2): "anonymous access" narrowed to censorship-resistant,
  location-hiding access, with correlation attacks and application
  metadata named as outside the threat model.

- 15 (P2): replaced the production-ready conclusion and its suitability
  assurance with implementation status plus an explicit statement of
  what this paper does not provide (threat model, security proof,
  conformance matrix, benchmarks).

- 8.9 (P3): recast backend retention from known-defect detail into
  durable terms — the bound is a backend property, not a protocol one.

- References: DIDComm entry labeled v2.0 but linked v2.1; label now
  matches the target. VC v1.1 ent... (continued)

2984 of 3535 branches covered (84.41%)

Branch coverage included in aggregate %.

6180 of 6606 relevant lines covered (93.55%)

840.8 hits per line